Alibi

Alibi #1 · hard · 15 Nov 2026

The Other Side of the Must Cup

0
actions

sabotage

Someone deliberately ruined Madame Varenne's blind Must Cup. At three she drew the lots in the yard and sent the fresh tally into the wicket. Its public face gave the tasting order; its private face paired every cup number with its grower. Before the hour bell finished striking, the private face was on display to the entire bench of judges, complete with a pasted heading. One may rinse a glass, as Madame observed, but not a judge.

From the yard Madame heard the chief judge read his own son-in-law's cup number aloud in astonishment. The other judges had seen the list too. The shutter hid whoever had set it in the frame.

When and where
In the The Tally Wicket, between 15:00 and 15:15.
Done to
Madame Léonie Varenne. The vineyard's owner and donor of the Must Cup. She remembers every favour she has ever done, usually in time to stop one thanking her twice.

The Monastery Vineyard of Saint Oran · Burgundy, 1932

The brothers tend the vines; Madame Varenne owns the ground. At harvest the six tenant growers bring their fresh grape must for a blind judging. The cup is silver, the portions are small, and the judges have been known to ask for bread between samples as if composing a symphony.

The suspects

Félix Avril

Cup calligrapher

A little man with a splendid moustache and a strip of India paper perpetually escaping from his cuff. Madame found him the Cup commission when the demand for illuminated addresses fell to nearly one a decade.

Berthe Colas

Deputy harvest steward

A tall woman with a green key cord and an immaculate copy of the order of proceedings. Madame created the deputyship especially for her. People have begun to ask when the deputy might take charge.

Nona Bellier

Abbey printer

She keeps her sleeves rolled to exactly the same height. Her paper hat is folded out of yesterday's unfavourable weather forecast. Madame stood surety for her new press when the bank would not.

Brother Ambrose

Monastery cellarer

A white-haired monk with damson-coloured cheeks. His niece is the youngest grower in the field. Madame reroofed his leaking cellar at her own expense and never asked the order for a sou.

Inès Salvat

Tenants' secretary

She wears a work apron over a very good suit. Six little sample bottles ride in its pockets without touching. Madame paid for her commercial schooling and now introduces her as the best investment the vineyard ever made.

Luc Perrin

Cooper

His belt holds three gauges and a pencil worn down to a remarkably determined stump. Madame bought a year's casks in advance so that his workshop could stay open.

The places

  • The Tally Wicket — A shuttered booth between yard and judging hall. Papers go in by a revolving drum and come out under glass. One cannot see into it from either side.
  • The Muniment Room — A cool reading room with a gated vestibule. Across from the gate, behind the long desk, is what looks like a perfectly good green door marked IMPRIMERIE. The windows are medieval arrow slits.
  • The Old Printery — A hand press occupies the sunny wall. Label specimens hang from a line like the washing of an exceptionally tidy doll.
  • The Press Yard — Grape tubs stand in double file under the monastery bell. The owner makes her draw here, in full view of the harvest hands.
  • The Harvest Refectory — Long trestles face the public side of the wicket. Six white cups are set at each judge's place.
Everyone will tell you where they were, every quarter of an hour. One of them is lying about the time of the crime. Find the clue or the witness that proves it, show it to them, and watch them crack. Every question, search and confrontation counts as one action. Only the culprit has to be right when you accuse; a wrong accusation costs 5 actions.