Alibi

Alibi #5 · easy · 19 Nov 2026

The Founder’s Missing Paragraph

0
actions

forgery

The founder's original signed letter is removed from its display and replaced with a freshly written imitation. The imitation preserves the signature and most of the wording but omits a paragraph about the founder's family.

At 21:00, Ada returns to prepare her reading and notices that the displayed letter lacks a paragraph she knows by heart. Nobody is injured, although Ada's opinion of the club's scholarship suffers considerably.

When and where
In the Club Office, between 20:45 and 21:00.
Done to
Miss Ada Bell. A meticulous collector who has lent the club its founder's original signed anniversary letter. She can detect imitation parchment at six paces, although she cannot persuade the drummer to play more quietly.

The Blue Teacup Jazz Club · London, 1927

Below a respectable hat shop, a decidedly less respectable trumpet announces the Blue Teacup's anniversary party. There are velvet curtains, ginger beer served in champagne glasses, and a display of memorabilia borrowed from a collector.

The suspects

Basil Vane

Club proprietor

An elegant man in his forties with a carnation in his buttonhole. He writes with his left hand and introduces himself as the founder's grandson. Borrowed Ada's letter for the anniversary exhibition and promised to read it aloud later.

Pearl March

Singer

A poised singer in a beaded dress who holds her pencil in her right hand. A country accent occasionally escapes between her grander vowels. Has a small, openly discussed wager with friends about whether Ada could spot a convincing imitation autograph.

Nora Finch

Drummer

A brisk woman with a scarlet headband and drum brushes tucked into her belt. She writes and handles her brushes left-handed. Ada rejected Nora's grandmother's musical memoirs as unsuitable for the exhibition, with rather unnecessary emphasis.

Hugh Tallow

Club treasurer

A narrow gentleman with immaculate cuffs, a right-handed fountain pen grip, and a persistent expression of financial disappointment. Owes Ada money from a publicly acknowledged loan and knows that her original letter would fetch a handsome price.

The places

  • Club Office — A compact office containing the anniversary display, a writing table, and enough unpaid stationery bills to furnish a second exhibition.
  • Band Room — A windowless rehearsal room with one doorway. Its floor has been varnished before the anniversary performance.
  • Refreshment Lounge — Small tables surround a raffle desk. The ginger beer is excellent; the raffle prizes include a knitted trumpet cosy.
  • Cloakroom — Coats and feathered hats crowd a narrow room. A fixed wall telephone occupies a screened alcove.
Everyone will tell you where they were, every quarter of an hour. One of them is lying about the time of the crime. Find the clue or the witness that proves it, show it to them, and watch them crack. Every question, search and confrontation counts as one action. Only the culprit has to be right when you accuse; a wrong accusation costs 5 actions.